Ice Cream: Diabetes Nutrition

Text Size:
Going to the Grocery Store With Diabetes: The Ice Cream and Frozen Novelty Aisle

Yes, it may be one of the colder sections of the grocery store, but the frozen dessert aisle is also the source of happy memories and the centerpiece of many celebrations. For those of us with diabetes, frozen confections were probably one of the first types of food that passed through our minds with a big red X on them as we got the news of our diagnosis. But now we know they don’t need to be condemned. Ice cream and frozen novelties can have a place in the diets of people with diabetes. Let’s discuss a few things about how we can have our ice cream cake and eat it too!

First off, ice cream and frozen yogurt — what is the difference? In a blog entry I wrote on my own site a couple years ago, I explain in detail how each differs in calories and carbohydrates. Here is a summary of what I uncovered:

Frozen yogurt is not necessarily the best option, especially for people with diabetes. While it is usually low in fat or fat-free, the fat has often been replaced with more sugar to add flavor. Also, frozen yogurt, depending on the brand, can contain unappealing ingredients such as corn syrup, artificial colors, and preservatives. Also, note that soft-serve ice cream is not frozen yogurt, a common point of confusion.

Ice cream in all its dairy richness is generally higher in fat and lower in total carbohydrates than its frozen yogurt counterpart, and it is often more natural. I may be a bit biased, but I personally would rather have a bowl of full-fat ice cream that I know will have a more predictable effect on my blood sugar (with a delayed rise due to the fat), rather than a bland frozen yogurt that will spike my numbers more quickly because of the higher sugar and lower fat content. At the end of the day, it is a personal choice. But just know that you can absolutely enjoy ice cream, in any form, as long as you keep your portions in control. It may be easier said than done, but portion control with any dessert is key to blood sugar and weight control.

As for other frozen novelties such as fudge pops, cream pops — any type of frozen pops — the same rules apply: If they are made up of mostly sugars and coloring, know that you will need to account for a fairly quick spike of your blood sugar, sort of like drinking juice. But if they have dairy, or fat of any kind, the impact on blood glucose may be offset slightly. Take a look at the Nutrition Facts label on the box; if the item has more than 12 grams of carbohydrate per serving (and depending on how sensitive you are to carbohydrate), you should probably account for it in your diabetes regimen. It may not always be possible to find or afford (or even really like) a more natural version of your nostalgic favorites, but if you can go without the added corn syrup and food dyes (especially for the kids), it’s better overall. Try the box that says “made from real fruit juice…” but first be sure to turn it around and check out the first three ingredients to make sure the box isn’t telling a fib.

Frozen cakes, ice cream sandwiches, sorbet, Italian ices, the list goes on. For the sake of your diabetes, try to keep it simple with frozen treats, and keep the sugary toppings to a minimum. And while it may be tempting to treat a low blood sugar with a frozen treat, note that it’s not the fastest choice, since it takes a bit of time to eat and melt. As for those taking insulin or other medication who need to account for the effects of a high-fat and high-sugar food, speak to your diabetes educator or dietitian about how to manage that. It is very much an individual trial-and-error project when adjusting insulin over time for the fat delay.

Now, go get a mini ice cream cake on your next Diaversary and wish yourself another healthy year!

How important is it for people with diabetes to stay hydrated? Some evidence shows it’s very important. Bookmark and tune in tomorrow to learn more.

Get Diabetes-Friendly Recipes In Your Inbox

Sign up for Free

Stay Up To Date On News & Advice For Diabetes

Sign up for Free

Get On Track With Daily Lifestyle Tips

Sign up for Free

Save Your Favorites

Save This Article