To print: Select File and then Print from your browser's menu
Transforming Food Habits
November 25, 2009
Last week I reviewed Dr. David Kessler’s book entitled The End of Overeating. Kessler says modern food marketing has addicted us to fat, sugar, and salt. He implies that these addictions are making us fat and damaging our health. He also says he can help us overcome them. I don’t think he can.
It’s clear to me that sugars and fats can be habit-forming. They affect our brains the same way that cigarettes or cocaine do, and their addictive quality has been demonstrated in many animal studies. In my book Diabetes: Sugar-Coated Crisis, I wrote that the unhealthy food environment is part of what makes people sick, although not the most important part. (Stress and physical inactivity are most important.)
It’s true that all the fat and sugar in our food tend to make us gain weight. But since reading Linda Bacon’s book Health at Every Size, I’m not sure that weight is causing much health damage. As Canadian, Japanese, and American studies show, weight is probably not a major cause of illness, except at the extremes of fatness or thinness.
So I disagree with Kessler on that. But I disagree even more with the last part of his book. That’s where he gives his program for escaping food addictions. In my opinion, his approach won’t benefit many people and may hurt a far larger group.
Changing habitual behavior is hard. I’ve written about this frequently, for example in this article for Rest Ministries called “Making Desirable Changes.” The reason I’m drawn to this topic is that, after studying it for years, I still find it really hard to change habits. I asked for help from the Diabetes Self-Management community on how to stop playing computer games and got some good advice. But it’s still a struggle. So I was interested in what Kessler had to say.
He correctly says that diets don’t work. But then he tells everyone to go on a very strict diet, like 1500 calories a day. He also says that willpower is not the answer. But his program is pretty much pure willpower.
Kessler says that habits, especially the food habits he calls “conditioned hypereating,” take over our behavior very quickly. Without even thinking, environmental triggers will have us eating that super-rich food. Since we don’t have time to think about it, we have to have very simple, very strict rules about a behavior we want to change.
You need a rule like “I don’t eat that, ever.” Or “I won’t go to parties where I’m going to be tempted by food I don’t want.” Or, I suppose, “I will never play a computer game, ever.”
Kessler says you may be able to lighten up on these rules eventually, but not until the old conditioning has been unlearned. And in an environment where food promises you relief, satisfaction, and pleasure 24/7, it might take a long time to unlearn.
Anyway, I tried his plan with the computer games. I wrote down in big letters on my desk, “I do not play computer games.” To my surprise, it actually worked…for three days. But then I found myself relapsing. The simple rule was not enough. I also had to identify my triggers and avoid them. If I couldn’t avoid them, I had to learn new ways of coping with them. I needed to find substitute behaviors that were incompatible with playing the games. I’m making some progress, but it’s challenging.
All habit change is like that. You need to identify the emotional needs that the habit meets. You have to figure out other ways of meeting those needs. You might need support to make such changes, perhaps from family, friends, or other people with the same problems.
Changing eating behaviors may be even more difficult. It’s not like gambling or heroin, where you can say “never again.” Food is a necessity, and it’s also a major source of comfort and pleasure, just as the advertisers claim. We don’t want food to become a source of anxiety. Stressing about eating won’t help our diabetes or our weight.
As I wrote in the Rest Ministries article, “Some people say that being healthy means giving up everything you like. They have it completely backward. Give up the things you don’t like, and appreciate the heck out of the things you do.” If food is a major source of emotional comfort, it would be crazy to try to give that up, without having found another way of comforting ourselves.
Taking the time to enjoy food might be the best way to get control of it. Increase the pleasure you get from food by tasting it thoroughly and eating slowly. Try to find foods you like even better, like maybe some of these Diabetes Self-Management recipes.
Slow down and listen to your body and you’ll probably eat the right amount. You can check your blood glucose after eating to make sure. I think that’s a better way to unlearn food conditioning than just trying to beat it down. Do you agree?
You can read my whole review of The End of Overeating here.
Disclaimer of Medical Advice:You understand that the blogs posts and comments to such blog posts (whether posted by us, our agents, bloggers, or by users) do not constitute medical advice or recommendation of any kind and you should not rely on any information contained on such posts or comments to replace consultations with your qualified health care professionals to meet your individual needs. The opinions and other information contained in the blog posts and comments do not reflect the opinions or positions of the Site Proprietor.