![]() | www.DiabetesSelfManagement.com |
|
To print: Select File and then Print from your browser's menu | |
|
URL: http://www.diabetesselfmanagement.com/blog/Amy_Campbell/Carb_Counting/Print
|
|
Carb CountingAmy Campbell Aug 21, 2006 @ 10:05 AM Last week we talked about two types of diabetes meal planning tools: the exchange system and the plate method. While both of these approaches can work well, today, more and more people with diabetes are turning to carbohydrate counting. Carbohydrate, or "carb", counting, really isn't all that new. In fact, Dr. Elliott Joslin taught carb counting to his patients back in the early part of the 20th Century: "In teaching patients their diet," he said, "I lay emphasis first on carbohydrate values, and teach to a few only the values for protein and fat." Patients who came to Joslin Clinic in those days were taught by Dr. Joslin himself, and today, the walls of Joslin Diabetes Center are lined with pictures of folks from that period sitting in a classroom with gram scales in front of them for the purpose of weighing their food. Since those days, many aspects of diabetes care have changed for the better, but carb counting has made a comeback as an effective yet simple approach to help people better manage their diabetes. There are actually two types of carb counting. The first type, often called basic or consistent carb counting (or, as one of the doctors at Joslin likes to say, "CC"), is usually what most people with diabetes learn about these days. Basic carb counting isn't a diet, but rather a tool to help you better plan meals and learn how your food choices affect your blood glucose levels. As you may know, most of the carbohydrate we eat turns to glucose (sugar) during digestion. Our bodies then use this glucose for energy. Let's review the types of foods that contain carbohydrate:
(Non-starchy vegetables, such as broccoli, green beans, and carrots have a little carb, but not enough to affect blood glucose levels unless you eat large amounts.) Many people "count" carbs using grams. One carb choice, or serving, is the amount of food that contains 15 grams of carbohydrate. Whether you eat 15 grams of carb from a piece of bread or 15 grams of carb from a cookie, the effect on your blood glucose level is about the same. (It's a common misconception that eating sweet foods causes your blood glucose level to climb higher than if you eat a starchy food.) You can learn how much carbohydrate is in your foods by reading food labels for serving size and total carbohydrate, as well as using a carb counting book that you can buy in any bookstore. The goal with basic carb counting is to aim to eat a consistent amount of carbohydrate at your meals on a day-to-day basis. If you eat more carbohydrate than usual at a meal, for example, you'll probably have a high glucose level later on. Eating a certain amount of carbohydrate at meals, along with getting regular physical activity and taking your diabetes medicine as prescribed, is an effective way of controlling blood glucose levels. How do you know how much carb you should aim for at your meals? A dietitian is the best person to help answer this. A dietitian takes into account your medication, food likes and dislikes, eating schedule, weight goals and overall diabetes control to come up with a carb amount that's best for you. If you're interested in trying carb counting, you might aim for about 45 to 60 grams of carbohydrate (or three to four carbohyrate choices) at each meal until you meet with a dietitian. On reviewing your individual needs, the dietitian may recommend eating more or less carbohydrate. The next type of carb counting is really more like the next "level" of carb counting. Sometimes it's called advanced carb counting, although it has nothing to do with how smart you are! Advanced carb counting is a very flexible way of meal planning that can be used by people who take fast-acting insulin (lispro, aspart, glulisine or Regular) before meals, whether by injection or via an insulin pump (you can't do advanced carb counting if you take only diabetes pills or long-acting insulin). Here's how it works: Right before you eat a meal, you figure out how much carbohydrate you'll be eating. Then, using something called an insulin-to-carb ratio, you calculate how much insulin you need to take to "cover" the carbohydrate in your meal. Let's say you have an insulin-to-carb ratio of 1:15. This means that you need to take 1 unit of your fast-acting insulin to cover every 15 grams of carb you eat. So, if you plan to eat 45 grams of carb at your meal, how much insulin would you need? If you guessed 3 units, you're right! Pretty easy to do! Of course, you need to keep a few things in mind. First, your health-care team (usually your dietitian) should help you figure out your own insulin-to-carb ratio. Ratios vary from person to person, and you may even need different ratios for different meals. Second, be prepared to keep food records and check your blood glucose levels after meals for a while to make sure your ratio is correct. Third, if your blood glucose level is too high before a meal, you need to take extra insulin, along with the insulin to cover your carbs. This extra insulin is called a correctional dose and also needs to be calculated with the help of your health-care team. Finally, while advanced carb counting really gives you the flexibility of eating as much or as little carb as you want while still maintaining good diabetes control, don't forget that you still want to eat a variety of foods and not load up on empty calories found in desserts and snack foods. Also, it's not uncommon for people to gain weight when they start adjusting their insulin for their food intake. If you're trying to lose or maintain your weight, you still may want to aim for a certain amount of carb at your meals, along with keeping portions of protein and fat foods in control, too. Carb counting is another meal planning tool that can help you manage your diabetes. Many people with diabetes find that carb counting helps them eat more like a person without diabetes because it's more flexible than other meal planning methods. If you think you'd like to try this approach, make an appointment with a dietitian to learn more about how carb counting can work for you. Disclaimer of Medical Advice:You understand that the blogs posts and comments to such blog posts (whether posted by us, our agents, bloggers, or by users) do not constitute medical advice or recommendation of any kind and you should not rely on any information contained on such posts or comments to replace consultations with your qualified health care professionals to meet your individual needs. The opinions and other information contained in the blog posts and comments do not reflect the opinions or positions of the Site Proprietor. | |
Comments:
Background: Type 1 for 45 years on pump.
When traveling and eating out for breakfast especially, I think I've counted right, but sometimes I misjudge carbs - then my blood glucose snowballs for the next 4-5 hours. Testing post-eating is the answer, I know, but it's not always possible. What causes the snowball effect? My blood glucose readings are so high prior to the next meal that it shocks me - I couldn't have misjudged that much!
Posted by: bpc | Aug 21, 2006 12:11 PM
There could be several reasons why your blood glucose "snowballs" after eating out for breakfast. First, keep in mind that when you eat away from home, portions tend to be much larger than you might think - in other words, you might be getting more carb than you bargain for. Second, is your breakfast high in fat? Fat can delay digestion of carbs, causing high glucose levels several hours later. Third, it's possible that the types of foods you're eating at breakfast have a high glycemic index, which can raise blood glucose levels higher and faster. Finally, since you're on a pump, you might need to use a different insulin-to-carb ratio on days when you eat breakfast out. It would be helpful if you could check a 3-hour post-meal blood glucose after eating breakfast out, just to get a sense of what's happening with your glucose at that time.
Posted by: acampbell | Aug 23, 2006 08:18 AM
As a new diabetic and a new user to your site I would suggest a "print article" option to to your list of options.
Posted by: LandSDistribu | Aug 26, 2006 10:19 AM
Any recommendations for helping a 10 year old getting control, She runs 250 - 350 at 11:30 am prior to lunch. She doesn't keep records, I have to teach her everything, she's not working with a nutritionist & Mom just tells her how much insulin to take prior to lunch!
Posted by: Lifelong commitment | Feb 09, 2007 10:17 AM
Hi Lifelong commitment,
It's great that you're so concerned about this child. I'm not sure how receptive or motivated the child is, but one of the real issues is getting her mom (and dad, if he's around) on board with the importance of diabetes management. While she's not too young to be doing some things herself for her diabetes care, she definitely needs the support of her mother. If you haven't already, you might try talking to her mom, expressing your concerns, especially about her high blood glucose readings. Give her some literature to read, or recommend a local diabetes class or a dietitian appointment. You might also mention that her daughter will physically feel better and will do better in school if her glucose levels are better controlled. If you know another parent with a child who has diabetes, suggest the parent talk to this child's mother, if both are willing. I hope all works out.
Posted by: acampbell | Feb 09, 2007 02:50 PM
What is your preferred way of calculating insulin:carb ratios...from your practice do you find pattern mgmt or the 500 rule works better.
Thanks
Posted by: New DM RD | Jun 17, 2007 10:07 PM
Hi New DM RD,
There are actually several ways to figure out an insulin-to-carb ratio for someone. I typically use the 500 rule, as I've found this tends to be a little more precise than basing the calculation on typical food intake and insulin doses. But, this is more of an art than a science, so either method can work. The most important part is to follow-up with the patient for fine-tuning of the ratio, as it almost always needs to be tweaked a little. And don't forget that people can have different ratios for different meals. Hope this helps!
Posted by: acampbell | Jun 18, 2007 12:20 PM
hi,
i am a pediatrician. i have an indian pt.in my office who happens to have type1 diabetes. can you please suggest a book or web site to calculate carb content of indian food.
thanks
gunpreet singh
Posted by: dr gunpreet singh | Aug 08, 2007 11:41 AM
dr gunpreet singh: go to http://www.mendosa.com/gilists.htm . scroll all the way to the bottom of the page. then slowly scroll up and the glycemic index and load for international foods, including Indian, will appear. it's not carb counting, but should be of help.
Posted by: barry | Sep 08, 2007 08:18 PM
What is the amount of fiber where you can subtract from the carbs. Example Fiber One
1/2 cup 25 grams Carbohydrate
14 grams of Fiber
I heard you subtract from carb any amount greater than 5 carbs.
So for Carb counting of Fiber One
25-14=11. Is that how many carbs to bolus for?
thanks
Posted by: glwfood | Apr 20, 2008 04:50 PM
Hi glwfood,
The "newer" guideline for subtracting fiber is this: if a food has more than 5 grams of fiber, subtract half those fiber grams from the total carb. Then, bolus for the resulting carbs. Therefore, in your example, you'd bolus for 18 grams of carb. Same applies to grams of sugar alcohols - subtract half those from the total carb, and then bolus for that amount. Confusing, isn't it?!
Posted by: acampbell | Apr 22, 2008 04:34 PM
What the heck does "bolus" mean?
Posted by: eileenmechler | Jul 17, 2008 07:49 AM
Hi Eileen,
An insulin bolus refers to the dose, or amount, of rapid/short acting insulin that you'd give before you eat a meal, or when you're correcting for a high glucose level. You can give a bolus with a syringe, insulin pen, or insulin pump.
Posted by: acampbell | Jul 17, 2008 03:08 PM
Hi, I was wanting to know if you can help me. I am very newly diagnosed with type 1 diabetes and I do have an appt. scheduled with the dietetion for the end of August because they are pretty booked. I believe I got the insulin to carb ratio understood. My doctor wants me to take insulin to carb ratio of 1:10. Just an example-if I plan on eating 50g. carbs then I would take 5 units, correct? He also gave me a correction of 1:25. So what I am having trouble with is this part. Could you help me figure out on the above example how much extra I will need after the 5 units?
Thanks,
Bonnie
Posted by: bmadams | Aug 01, 2008 10:39 PM
Hi Bonnie,
Glad to hear you'll be meeting with a dietitian. You're correct about how to use your insulin to carb ratio. In order to use your correction factor, you need to know two things: what your current BG level is and what your target BG is. For example, let's say your pre-meal BG is 200 and your target is 150. You know you need to come down 50 points. You then divide your correction factor, 25, into 50 and you get 2. That means you need 2 units of insulin to "correct" for your high BG. But be sure to add that to the insulin you need to cover your food. If you were taking 5 units to cover your carbs, you'd add 2 units to correct, for a total of 7 units. Of course, make sure you use your own BG and target levels! Hope this helps.
Posted by: acampbell | Aug 04, 2008 01:46 PM
Hey Amy,
Thanks for the reply for the correction factor. So tonight before supper my Blood Glucose was 210, and my goal is 140. I ate 35 carbs for supper so I need 3.5 units for an insulin to carb ratio of 1:10, and for the correction of 1:25 I need 2.8 units. so I will needed 6.3 units total. Is this right? Just making sure. I don't want to get too low or high and have problems. Any how it's really hard to do the 6.3 so what do I do for the 10ths? Just go a little over or would 6 units be ok?
I really appreciate all your help and thank you again for the reply.
Bonnie
Posted by: bmadams | Aug 04, 2008 09:18 PM
Hi Bonnie,
Yes, your calculations are right on! Unless you're on an insulin pump, you really can't bolus 6.3 units, so I would round down to 6 units. It's also good to be on the conservative side when you first start carb counting. Be sure to check your blood glucose about 3 hours after your meal to see how things worked out. When you meet with the dietitian later this month, make sure he or she reviews how to check the accuracy of both your insulin to carb ratio and your correction factor. Also, keep in mind that you may have different ratios for different meals. Be patient, keep good records and don't get too frustrated if you don't always see the numbers that you want. All in all, this is a flexible and practical meal planning and insulin regime.
Posted by: acampbell | Aug 05, 2008 12:52 PM
Hi Amy,
My 9 year old was diagnosed last Christmas and we just got him on an insulin pump about 2 weeks ago. We are having a really hard time with his BG at recess now - which is about 2 1/4 hours after breakfast. We have always had him test before his snack at recess, but now he is really running high, close to 300. We have raised his basal rate from 7am-11am from .35 to .375 to .4 and also hid I:C ratio from 15 to 12. I think when he was on lantus his BG was about 80-100 and his BG target right now is 120. I am working with the endo and pump folks, but it is so frustrating. How do I know what we should change next his basal or IC? Any thoughts?
Thanks,
Bevin
Posted by: Bevin | Oct 04, 2008 03:09 AM
Hi Bevin,
I can imagine how frustrating it is for you and your son to see these high glucose readings. What may be helpful is to focus initially on your son's basal rates to be sure they're correct. Most people focus first on the overnight basals (because they're easier to start with!)and then move on to the morning basal(which means skipping breakfast and morning snack), and so forth. If the basals aren't correct, it's then hard to establish the insulin to carb ratio. Your son's team may take a different approach, but I'd suggest you and your son focus on one thing at a time, starting with basal evaluations.
Posted by: acampbell | Oct 06, 2008 02:08 PM